50 pages 1 hour read

Colson Whitehead

Harlem Shuffle

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

The City

Ray lives in New York City, but he considers himself an inhabitant of Harlem. The neighborhood of Harlem functions as a symbolic city-within-a-city, a boundary which defines the racial lines between White and Black New York. In Harlem, Ray feels comfortable. He knows the streets, he recognizes the faces, and he never feels out of place. In the White neighborhoods of the city, however, he is uneasy. He is made to feel unwelcome. The people on the streets, the salesmen in the stores, and every White person he encounters in the city outside Harlem is aware that he does not belong in the neighborhood. The existence of Harlem within New York City, along with other African American neighborhoods, creates a physical symbol of society’s racial divide. African Americans are pushed to the side of White society and forced to create their own communities and institutions in a world which is not intended for them.

As the novel develops, however, Ray is shown a different kind of Harlem. He learns that criminality is more pervasive than he ever thought possible. As he journeys through the streets, he comes to learn about secret card games, drunk dens, and brothels which operate behind seemingly innocent doors. The businesses that he always ignored cater to criminals and other fringe members of society. The irony of this revelation is that Ray’s business operates in the same manner. As such, the revelation becomes a symbol of his need for self-delusion.

By the end of the novel, the city is beginning to change. The stores and businesses which Ray visits in the opening chapters are forcibly removed from their neighborhoods in the name of development. These family-owned stores have been in the same location for generations, but they are replaced by the quickly erected skyscrapers which feature the name of Van Wyck’s development firms among others. This radical regeneration of the traditional communities is a symbol of the rapid change taking over the city. The world Ray knew as a youngster is gone—crushed in the pursuit of money and fortunes associated with the towering skyscrapers but which require the removal of smaller, independent businesses. The old world is dying and the new world is being imposed on communities, most of which have no influence on their place in society. Ultimately, profit triumphs over everything else.

Furniture

Furniture is a symbol of Ray’s relationship with the world. It illustrates the way he wants to be seen by the world, the way he sees the world, and the reality of the world he inhabits. Ray first becomes a furniture salesman because he views furniture as a good, honest career path. As a person who is inextricably linked with the reputation of his criminal father, he wants to redefine his family name in Harlem. By selling furniture, he can force people to associate the name Carney with the store that bears his name, rather than his father’s crimes. He devotes himself to the trade and learns every detail he can about his products. He is so desperate to make a real name for himself that he becomes a self-taught expert.

After teaching himself everything about furniture, Ray begins to see the world in a new light. Every person’s home is an insight into their attitude and material conditions. He can examine the furniture in a house or an office and learn about the owner. The presence of a low-quality chair indicates a poor or uncaring person in Ray’s view, while the presence of high-quality, difficult-to-obtain luxury furniture shows him that he is dealing with rich and powerful people. In times of stress, Ray examines the furniture around him to give himself a mooring. He uses his furniture expertise to interpret the world around him. His expertise relies on symbolism, creating a lens through which he views the world.

Just like people, furniture is segregated along racial lines. Certain products or stores only cater to White people, to the extent that Ray must spend years arranging a meeting with the sales representative of a certain brand so that he can become the first African American vendor for the company. Likewise, he still recalls how interactions with certain brands and stores were predicated along racial lines. His African American customers share this view, associating certain items and brands with rich White people. In their minds, these brands are aspirational, as they represent a degree of success and social acceptance which is denied to the African American members of society. The segregation of furniture is a subtle symbolic reflection of the broader segregation which exists in Ray’s Harlem.

Weapons

Weapons and their wielders are symbols of the power dynamic which operates in Harlem. As instruments of violence, guns represent the seedier side of life in the city. They are mostly limited to the criminal elements of society, meaning that the presence of a gun in any situation suggests that some element of crime is taking place. The characters who are most familiar with guns are those who have made their peace with this symbolic association. Pepper is completely at home wielding a pistol, illustrating his lack of self-delusion: He knows that he is a criminal and a practical part of criminality is being able to wield a weapon. In turn, weapons confuse and worry Ray. He keeps a pistol in the office but never wants to use it. Even in the final showdown with Ed Bench, he deliberately refuses to take a pistol. Ray does not consider himself to be a criminal, so he has no expectation that he should be able to fire a gun. The willingness of characters to use a weapon symbolizes the extent to which they are integrated into the criminal underworld, as well as the extent to which they believe themselves to be a criminal.

Ray’s pistol also has a more personal symbolic value. He inherited the pistol from his father, but he has never fired this gun. The pistol sits in the drawer in his office, out of sight but available if he ever requires it. To this extent, the pistol is an ever-present symbol of Ray’s relationship with his criminal father. Like the pistol, Ray has inherited character traits from his father. He is meticulous and determined, particularly in matters of revenge. These character traits are hidden away from view, placed behind the veneer of respectability which Ray has worked hard to establish. Like the pistol, Ray tries to keep his father’s influence and reputation hidden from the world, but they are there if and when they are required. The pistol is a symbol of the burden of the expectations and reputation placed on Ray by his father.

However, not every criminal needs to use a weapon. For rich and powerful criminals like Wilfred Duke and Ambrose Van Wyck, the implication of violence is usually enough. When violence becomes necessary, these rich men do not need to use weapons themselves, as they can hire other men to commit violence on their behalf. Their hands remain clean, while their poorer henchmen carry out their orders. The absence of weapons from the lives of men like Van Wyck and Duke symbolizes the importance of money, power, and influence. The richest and most powerful men in the city may be just as criminal as any of the poorer characters, but they are insulated from repercussions by their wealth.